Jack the Giant Slayer is a classic example of a movie that is greater than the sum of its parts in some ways and far less in others. As a technical achievement in CGI and world-building, it is often stunning. As a piece of storytelling, it is functional at best.
The cast also does its best with the material. Nicholas Hoult makes for a likable, everyman hero—not a born warrior, but a clever survivalist. Ewan McGregor, sporting a goofy Prince Valiant haircut, is the film’s secret weapon; his Elmont is a swashbuckling, honorable soldier who brings a much-needed dose of charm and wit. Stanley Tucci, as the treacherous Roderick, seems to be having the time of his life, chewing the sparse medieval scenery with a modern, smarmy villainy. The brief scenes between Ian McShane and Eleanor Tomlinson also hint at a more interesting political drama that the film never fully explores. jack and the giants movie
The film follows Jack (Nicholas Hoult), a young, impoverished farmhand living in the kingdom of Cloister. He’s dreamy but practical, until he inadvertently trades his horse for a handful of “magic” beans. Meanwhile, the headstrong Princess Isabelle (Eleanor Tomlinson) flees an arranged marriage and seeks refuge at Jack’s farm. A rainstorm, a dropped bean, and a cracked floor later, a colossal beanstalk erupts into the sky, carrying the princess’s house—and the princess herself—into the realm of the clouds. Jack the Giant Slayer is a classic example
Fans of high-fantasy CGI spectacle, those who don’t mind plot holes the size of a giant’s footprint, and anyone who wants to see Ewan McGregor deliver a Shakespearean speech while hanging off a vine. The cast also does its best with the material
The giants, too, are a technical triumph. This isn't the friendly BFG or the lumbering oafs of Jack and the Beanstalk cartoons. Singer’s giants are disgusting, terrifying, and brilliantly realized. They have two heads (one of which is just a gnarly, face-like growth), skin like old stone, and an insatiable hunger. Their leader, Fallon (voiced with menacing glee by Bill Nighy in motion capture), is a genuinely imposing villain. The sound design—the ground-shaking thud of each footstep—adds a palpable sense of dread.
You demand tight scripts, deep character development, or a consistent tone.