The cheating dad. We hated him then. We still hate him now.
The sweet, athletic soul of the group. Season 1 is all about Emily’s journey of self-discovery—coming to terms with her sexuality while dealing with Maya’s flirting and a closet (literally and figuratively) full of anxiety. Shay’s quiet strength made Emily the Liar you just wanted to give a hug. The Leading Men (and the Creeps) You can’t have Rosewood without a few complicated love interests. pretty little liars season one cast
Yes, he’s technically a villain (hello, statutory), but Ian’s brooding charm convinced a generation that Fitzgerald books were hot. Season 1 Ezra is all tortured glances and “I can’t do this, but let’s do it anyway.” The cheating dad